Pizza restaurants

The Joey's Pizza

4.1 379 reviews 5:00 AM - 10:00 PM 6941 OH-753, Hillsboro, OH 45133, United States

Discover this place

The Joey's Pizza, nestled at 6941 OH-753 in Hillsboro, OH, is a culinary gem that perfectly captures the essence of a local pizza restaurant. With a menu that includes mouthwatering pizzas and the crowd-favorite spicy broasted chicken, this place has something for everyone. Many customers rave about their delicious Bosco sticks and the enticing Mystic Retreat cheesecake, making it hard to resist indulging in multiple items.

Customer experiences reflect the restaurant's commitment to quality. As noted by Sara Bond, the welcoming staff, particularly Trish, adds a personal touch, enhancing the overall dining experience. Joe Arthur's review highlights the vintage atmosphere, invoking nostalgia as you await your meal prepared in an old-school pizza oven. Carrie Day's feedback points to the deep-fried chicken as a minor letdown, yet her positive note on the pizza indicates that the main attraction holds strong.

Despite occasional delays during busy times, as Jo noted, the freshness and quality of the food make the wait worthwhile. With friendly service and a cozy ambiance, The Joey's Pizza stands out as a must-try destination for both locals and travelers. Whether you're after a loaded pizza or a hearty Italian sub, this spot promises satisfaction on every visit.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner

Dining options

Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with The Joey's Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for The Joey's Pizza

4.1

379 reviews

100%

53%

23%

10%

12%

Review highlights

Based on 379 reviews

The Joey's Pizza in Hillsboro, OH, is well-regarded for its flavorful pizzas and hearty sandwiches, notably Italian subs and specialty items like spicy broasted chicken. Customers appreciate the friendly, attentive staff and the welcoming, nostalgic atmosphere, often highlighting the personable service and community feel. While the food is consistently praised for quality and portion size, some patrons note occasional wait times during busy periods. There are mixed feelings about the broasted chicken preparation, with some finding it less satisfactory. Overall, The Joey's Pizza is seen as a local favorite offering a solid dining experience with a blend of good food, warm service, and a charming, old-school vibe.

Carrie Day

Jul 27, 2025

Pizza is great! We wanted broasted chicken. It's not broasted. It's deep fried and bland, greasy. Other than that everything was wonderful. Travelers

Sara Bond

Jul 21, 2025

Our family loves the spicy broasted chicken and the Big T sandwiches. This place gets 5 stars for the great food and kind people; especially Trish who helped me out with a car juggling issue today that would have taken me several hours to get situated alone but with her help took less than 20min. It was such a huge blessing She is awesomeThank you!!

joe Arthur

May 21, 2025

Woah, a local must stop every Rocky Fork trip! From the classic tunes they’re playing to the loaded up pizzas cooking in the old school pizza oven , the vibes are immaculate. While sometimes the kitchen can definitely take a while with call in orders stacking up the wait is definitely worth it. Always try to get up there early enough in the day to chat it up with the man, Joey himself. 10/10 would recommend

May 12, 2025

Nice little food spot tucked into a general type store. We ordered an Italian sub and some wedges. Delicious. They were busy.... they get a lot of business, I hope. We had to wait for it and it came out fresh and perfect. There was another customer who was not happy with waiting.. and he was rude to the staff. Just wanted to say... you're doing a fine job folks.. and can't make everyone happy.

Michael G

May 03, 2025

Had an Italian sub from here for lunch. Good size sandwich for a reasonable price.

Michael Rector

Apr 23, 2025

Ordered a large pizza and it was one of the best pizzas we've had, beats other pizza chains

Aron Riley

Apr 15, 2025

Excellent cold cut sandwiches and cold soda pop. Also, my daughter and I had a great Father's Day fishing at Rocky Fork Lake.